EU warns China over HK security law

Europe-China ties are tangled in disagreement on trade, investment, rights, security and rising mistrust; the EU also accused Beijing of a campaign of disinformation on the coronavirus 

by AFP
EU warns China over HK security law
European Council President Charles Michel speaks to the media in Brussels after he and EC chief Ursula Von Der Leyen (not seen) talked to Chinese leaders via video conference on June 22, 2020. Photo: Dursun Aydemir / Anadolu Agency via AFP.

The EU warned China it would face "very negative consequences" if it presses ahead with a new security law for Hong Kong, stepping up pressure on Beijing over the controversial legislation.

European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and European Council chief Charles Michel told China's top leaders of their "grave concern" over the new law, which critics say will curb the financial hub's autonomy and freedoms.

The stern message, delivered during a video summit on Monday with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang, adds to a chorus of international concern over Hong Kong, though Beijing has shown no sign of backing down on a law it says is necessary to maintain order.

"We expressed our grave concerns about the proposed national security law for Hong Kong," Michel told reporters after the talks.

"We called on China to follow the promises made to the people of Hong Kong and the international community regarding Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy and guaranteed freedoms."

In response to the EU comments, China's foreign ministry said on Tuesday that matters relating to Hong Kong were a "domestic affair".

"We oppose any foreign interference in this matter," ministry spokesman Wang Lutong told reporters at a briefing, saying that Chinese leaders had "expressed our position" at the video summit.

A report of the summit by China's state news agency Xinhua made no mention of Hong Kong but said Xi had stressed his country wanted "peace without hegemony".

Foreign ministers from the G7 group of industrialised nations last week urged Beijing to reconsider the proposed law, which has raised concerns it will end Hong Kong's relative freedoms and open the door to the kind of repression seen in mainland China.

Echoing the language of the G7 statement, von der Leyen said they had made it clear to the Chinese that the EU believes the imposition of the national security law breaches Beijing's international commitments.

'Very negative consequences'

"The national security law risks seriously undermining the 'One country, two systems' principle and Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy, which we wish to see stay in place."

Von der Leyen said she had warned the Chinese leaders that Hong Kong owes its economic success to its relative autonomy from Beijing.

"So we also conveyed that China risks very negative consequences if it goes forward with imposing this law," she said.

Under the "One country, two systems" agreement made before Britain handed the territory back to China in 1997, Beijing agreed to let Hong Kong maintain certain liberties until 2047 – including legislative and judicial independence and freedom of speech.

But after a year of huge and often violent rallies that have morphed into a popular call for democracy and police accountability, Beijing says the new law is needed to end unrest and restore stability.

Cyber complaints

China and the EU both profess to want to strengthen ties, but the relationship is tangled in a thicket of disagreements on topics ranging from trade and investment rules to human rights and national security.

And Monday's talks came against a backdrop of rising tensions and increasing mistrust between Brussels and Beijing.

The EU has been angered by what it says is a significant Chinese campaign of disinformation around the coronavirus pandemic, which originated in China.

"We have seen cyber attacks on hospitals and dedicated computing centres. Likewise we've seen a rise on online disinformation, and we pointed out clearly that this cannot be tolerated," von der Leyen said.

The EU has in recent months sought to tread a delicate path with China, characterising it as a "systemic rival" and competitor but also as a partner on some issues.

But Monday's statements were sharper and more critical in tone.

EU lack of unity

Up to now the EU's efforts to stand up to Xi's increasingly assertive China have been stymied by a lack of unity among its 27 member states, many of which have been courted assiduously by the Asian giant.

Going into the summit, Chinese officials grumbled about proposed new EU legislation aimed at ensuring foreign firms backed by heavy state subsidies do not distort competition in Europe.

There is particular concern about Chinese companies swooping in to buy European companies weakened by the coronavirus-triggered recession.

According to Xinhua, Xi said the economies of China and Europe should become a "dual engine of the world economy" to promote recovery after the pandemic.

After the summit, von der Leyen said there needed to be "more ambition" from the Chinese side to conclude a stalled investment agreement.

AFP