Tesla faces a long, bumpy road if it’s to avoid gridlock in India 

Analysts say the US EV car-maker faces unique challenges if it’s to succeed on the sub-continent – supply chain issues, poor roads and congestion to name just a few. And affordability will be a problem too for the country’s less than affluent masses 

by Aditi Shah
Tesla faces a long, bumpy road if it’s to avoid gridlock in India 
The world's most valuable car manufacturer registered a local company in India earlier this month. Photo: Reuters

Tesla is gearing up for its India launch but the US electric car-maker is likely to remain a niche player there for years, catering only to the rich and affluent in the world's second-most populous nation.

India's fledgling electric vehicle (EV) market accounted for only 5,000 out of a total 2.4 million cars sold in the country last year. A lack of local production of components and batteries, negligible charging infrastructure and the high cost of EVs mean there have been few takers in a price-conscious market.

It's also difficult to see how Tesla's sought-after and expensive autonomous driving features will work on India's congested roads.

Read more: Rare earth stocks rise again in China trading

Ammar Master, a forecaster at consultancy LMC Automotive, said he expects Tesla to annually sell only 50 to 100 of its Model 3 electric sedans in India, at least in the first five years. 

"As a country, India is still not so environmentally conscious to pay that much of a premium," Master said. 

"It always comes down to the price point. There will be some high net-worth individuals like movie stars and top business executives who will look at it for the brand value. But then, how many buyers are there?"

The world's most valuable automobile manufacturer registered a local company in India earlier this month, a step towards its entry into the country, which is expected to happen in the middle of this year.

IMPORT PLANS

Tesla plans to import and sell the Model 3 in India for around $65,000 to $75,000 – roughly double its price in the US, sources said.

This means it will compete in India's even smaller luxury EV segment that has started seeing interest from the likes of Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) and Daimler's Mercedes-Benz.

The Mercedes-Benz EQC, India's first luxury EV launched in October for $136,000, has since sold 31 units, according to auto researcher JATO Dynamics. British luxury carmarker JLR, owned by India's Tata Motors, plans to launch its I-PACE EV before March. It sells in the United States for around $70,000.

Although India's road infrastructure has improved in recent years, traffic discipline – like lane driving – is still rudimentary. Auto analysts say that means many of Tesla's features, like the automatic lane changing function, will be tough to deploy on crowded Indian streets. 

STRAY CATTLE

Stray animals, including cattle, and potholes on the road are a further problem.

"Most of Tesla's high technology features will be redundant and users will not get the bang for the buck despite paying premium prices", said Ravi Bhatia, president for India at JATO Dynamics.

India has some of the world's most polluted cities and wants more clean cars on its roads, but the federal government still does not have a comprehensive policy like China which mandates car-makers to invest in the segment.

One reason is that auto manufacturers have pushed back saying there is no demand for EVs in India as the cost of components like batteries remain high and push up prices.

IMPORT TAXES

And Tesla CEO Elon Musk has himself expressed concern about India's high import taxes on cars.

In contrast to India, China sold 1.25 million new energy passenger vehicles, including EVs, in 2020 out of total sales of 20 million.

Tesla is a major player in China, where it also has a factory and which last year accounted for more than a third of the carmaker's global sales, according to JATO Dynamics.

Daniel Ives, of US-based Wedbush Securities, said, however, that within 7 to 8 years, India could account for 5% of Tesla's total sales. The key to success though will be local manufacturing, he said.

"It is a matter of when, not if, they build out a factory in India," said Ives, adding that building out a local supply chain will be a multi-year effort. "India is a potential sweet spot and Tesla does not want to be late to the game."

  • Reuters

Also on ATF:

India seen gaining from post-Covid supply chain shift  

IndiGo flying high as it tightens grip in India and targets growth abroad 

Survival of the smartest in China’s crowded NEV market

EV Tesla India Electric vehicle Model 3